IB Biology · Theme D · D4.1

Selection,
in action.

Natural selection isn't a theory of origins. It's a theory of change. And it's never stopped working.

15Sub-topics
37Key terms
SL+HLLevel
EcosystemsLevel of organisation
D4.1
Why this topic

What this topic answers.

Every sub-topic below feeds at least one of these questions.

Guiding question 1

What processes can cause changes in allele frequencies within a population?

Guiding question 2

What is the role of reproduction in the process of natural selection?

D4.1.1 – D4.1.8 · Standard Level

8 things to lock in.

The required syllabus content for D4.1, in order. Each card is one lesson-sized checkpoint.

D4.1.1

Natural selection as the mechanism driving evolutionary change

Nature of Science: In Darwin’s time it was widely understood that species evolved, but the mechanism was not clear.

D4.1.2

Roles of mutation and sexual reproduction in generating the variation on which natural selection acts

Mutation generates new alleles and sexual reproduction generates new combinations of alleles.

D4.1.3

Overproduction of offspring and competition for resources as factors that promote natural selection

Overproduction of offspring and competition for resources as factors that promote natural selection

D4.1.4

Abiotic factors as selection pressures

Abiotic factors as selection pressures

D4.1.5

Differences between individuals in adaptation, survival and reproduction as the basis for natural selection

Differences between individuals in adaptation, survival and reproduction as the basis for natural selection

D4.1.6

Requirement that traits are heritable for evolutionary change to occur

Requirement that traits are heritable for evolutionary change to occur

D4.1.7

Sexual selection as a selection pressure in animal species

Sexual selection as a selection pressure in animal species

D4.1.8

Modelling of sexual and natural selection based on experimental control of selection pressures

Modelling of sexual and natural selection based on experimental control of selection pressures

D4.1.1 · Natural selection

The mechanism Darwin figured out.

Natural selection is the differential survival and reproduction of individuals based on heritable traits. Four conditions, one mechanism.

  1. Variation — individuals in a population differ from each other.
  2. Heritability — some of that variation is heritable (passed via DNA).
  3. Differential survival/reproduction — some variants survive and reproduce better than others in the current environment.
  4. Differential offspring — favourable traits become more common in the next generation; unfavourable traits become rarer.

Over generations, the population evolves — its mean trait values shift, or it splits into new lineages. Without all four conditions, no evolution. With them, evolution is inevitable.

D4.1.2 · Types of selection

Three shapes of selection.

Selection can favour one extreme, both extremes, or the middle of a trait distribution — producing three characteristic patterns.

Directional

Shifts the mean

Selection favours one extreme. Mean of the trait distribution moves toward that extreme over generations. Examples: peppered moths darkening with pollution; bacteria evolving antibiotic resistance.

Stabilising

Reduces variation

Selection favours the average and disfavours extremes. Variation decreases. Birth weight in humans (very small and very large babies have lower survival) is the textbook example.

Disruptive

Splits into two

Selection favours both extremes and disfavours intermediates. Can drive speciation — populations split into two with different optimal trait values.

D4.1.3 · Industrial melanism

Peppered moths in real time.

Classic case of directional selection driven by environmental change.

Biston betularia — peppered moths in 19th-century Britain. Two forms: light (camouflaged on lichen-covered trees) and dark/melanic (rare, conspicuous).

  1. Industrial Revolution: pollution killed lichens; tree bark darkened with soot.
  2. Light moths now stood out against dark bark — picked off by predators.
  3. Dark moths became camouflaged — survived and reproduced more.
  4. Frequency of dark moths rose dramatically; within decades dark moths dominated industrial areas.
  5. When pollution was reduced, lichens returned, light moths recovered. Reversal of selection.
D4.1.4 · Sexual selection

Selection for mating success.

Selection acts not just on survival but on reproduction. Traits that make individuals more attractive or successful at mating spread, even when costly.

Two flavours:

Sexually selected traits are often costly to survival but spread anyway — because reproductive success matters more than longevity for fitness.

D4.1.5 · Antibiotic resistance

Evolution we can watch happen.

Bacterial populations evolve resistance to antibiotics within months or years of clinical use. Same mechanism as all natural selection.

  1. Random mutations occasionally produce resistance alleles in bacteria.
  2. In the presence of antibiotic, resistant bacteria survive while susceptible ones die.
  3. Resistant bacteria reproduce; resistance alleles become more common.
  4. Eventually the antibiotic stops working — the bacterial population is dominated by resistant strains.

This is why overuse of antibiotics (in medicine and agriculture) accelerates resistance — and why developing new antibiotics is a perpetual scientific arms race.

HL extension

Higher Level only.

An extra 7 sub-topics for HL — same syllabus, deeper mechanism.

HL only

Concept of the gene pool

Concept of the gene pool

HL only

Allele frequencies of geographically isolated populations

Allele frequencies of geographically isolated populations

HL only

Changes in allele frequency in the gene pool as a consequence of natural selection between individuals according to differences in their heritable traits

Changes in allele frequency in the gene pool as a consequence of natural selection between individuals according to differences in their heritable traits

HL only

Differences between directional, disruptive and stabilizing selection

Differences between directional, disruptive and stabilizing selection

HL only

Hardy–Weinberg equation and calculations of allele or genotype frequencies

Hardy–Weinberg equation and calculations of allele or genotype frequencies

HL only

Hardy–Weinberg conditions that must be maintained for a population to be in genetic equilibrium

Hardy–Weinberg conditions that must be maintained for a population to be in genetic equilibrium

HL only

Artificial selection by deliberate choice of traits

Artificial selection by deliberate choice of traits

HL-only key terms

Gene PoolReproductive IsolationGeographical IsolationNeo-DarwinismGeneticsStabilizing SelectionDirectional SelectionDisruptive SelectionHardy-Weinberg EquationHardy-Weinberg PrincipleArtificial SelectionSelective Breeding
Vocabulary

25 terms to own.

If you can't define one of these in a sentence, that's where to revise next.

EvolutionNatural SelectionBiodiversityParadigmParadigm ShiftMutationSexual ReproductionVariationGenetic VariationAlleleGeneMeiosisCrossing OverIndependent AssortmentGametesCarrying CapacityCompetitionBiotic FactorsAbiotic FactorsSelection PressurePhenotypeGenotypeDensity Independent FactorsIntraspecific CompetitionSexual Selection

IB Linking Questions

“How do intraspecific interactions differ from interspecific interactions?”

“What mechanisms minimize competition?”

“For what reasons do organisms need to distribute materials and energy?”